Lebanese man Mr Talal Ahmad Roda jailed for life for unlawful importing and storage of prohibited arms in kano have been set free.
The supreme court said the Federal high court in Abuja have no jurisdiction to conduct the trial,this decision have made those involved escape punishment despite the fact that importation of illegal firearms and possession is an offence.
Justice Musa Mohammed in his judgement, back by 4 other judges said since the offence was committed in kano the suspect should have be tried in Kano Federal High court.
Justice Musa Said
"In my considered view, the decision
of the Abuja Division of the trial court to try an offence which took
place in Kano and bears no relationship whatsoever with the offence in
Abuja having not stemmed from any provision of the enabling statutes, is
manifestly perverse.
"By virtue of Section 45(a) of the
FHC Act and the similar provisions contained in section 64 of the
Criminal Procedure Act, the appellant could only be tried by the Kano
division of the trial court within which territorial expanse the offence
was committed.
"The absence of any evidence to
suggest any understanding between the appellant and others in Abuja or a
link between the storage of the firearms at Kano and those in Abuja
further disentitle the Abuja Division's assumption of jurisdiction under
sections 45(b)-(e) of the FHC Act and or the similar provisions in the
criminal Procedure Act."
His Lordship also held that Roda was
not charged under any known law. According to him, the offence of
conspiracy is not contemplated under Section 1(14) (a)(i) of the
Miscellaneous Offences Act Cap M17 Laws of the Federation 2004.
Justice Muhammad said: "It is trite
that where the prosecution fails to charge an accused person for an
offence known to law, an appeal against condition under the incompetent
charge will succeed.
"In the sum, the appeal succeeds.
The proceedings of the lower court and that of the trial court it
purports to affirm are hereby set aside. The conviction and sentence of
the appellant, consequentially are hereby quashed
Source ThisDay
Source ThisDay
No comments:
Post a Comment